20 Best Fireplace Inserts Consumer Reports in 2024 Reviews and Buying Guide

3,285 Reviews Scanned

# Preview Product Rating
1 Cheerway 18 Inches Electric Fireplace Insert for Mantel and Tv Stand, Realistic Flame Fireplace... Cheerway 18 Inches Electric Fireplace Insert for Mantel and Tv Stand, Realistic Flame Fireplace... No ratings yet
2 COSTWAY Electric Fireplace Inserts 23-inch Wide, 1500W Recessed Fireplace Insert with Remote... COSTWAY Electric Fireplace Inserts 23-inch Wide, 1500W Recessed Fireplace Insert with Remote... No ratings yet
3 Joy Pebble Electric Fireplace Insert Log Heater 21',750W/1500W Adjustable 5 Flame Brightness&Speed,... Joy Pebble Electric Fireplace Insert Log Heater 21",750W/1500W Adjustable 5 Flame... No ratings yet
4 FLASLD Fireproof Fireplace Mat 24×42Inch Half Round Hearth Rug Protects Floors from Sparks Embers,... FLASLD Fireproof Fireplace Mat 24×42Inch Half Round Hearth Rug Protects Floors from Sparks... No ratings yet
5 PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound, Remote Control, 750/1500W,... PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound, Remote Control, 750/1500W,... No ratings yet
6 LegendFlame 25' W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF484), Fireplace Insert, Heater... LegendFlame 25" W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF484), Fireplace Insert, Heater... No ratings yet
7 COSTWAY Electric Fireplace Insert 26-inch Wide, 5,000 BTU Recessed and Freestanding Fireplace Heater... COSTWAY Electric Fireplace Insert 26-inch Wide, 5,000 BTU Recessed and Freestanding Fireplace... No ratings yet
8 Fireplace Grate Ember Retainer 12 * 8in, Heavy Duty Solid Steel, Add Support to Fire Logs on Grate,... Fireplace Grate Ember Retainer 12 * 8in, Heavy Duty Solid Steel, Add Support to Fire Logs on... No ratings yet
9 BWK1360 Fireplace Tray BWK1360 Fireplace Tray No ratings yet
10 Ashley Hearth AW1820E 1,200 Sq. Ft. Wood Stove Insert , Black Ashley Hearth AW1820E 1,200 Sq. Ft. Wood Stove Insert , Black
11 PuraFlame Klaus Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound, Glass Door and Mesh Screen,... PuraFlame Klaus Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound, Glass Door and Mesh Screen,...
12 ORALNER Electric Fireplace Insert 23 Inch, 3-Sided Glass Fireplace Heater w/Remote Control & 8H... ORALNER Electric Fireplace Insert 23 Inch, 3-Sided Glass Fireplace Heater w/Remote Control & 8H... No ratings yet
13 Signature Design by Ashley 24' Electric Infrared Fireplace Insert with Remote Control, Black Signature Design by Ashley 24" Electric Infrared Fireplace Insert with Remote Control, Black No ratings yet
14 Rintuf Electric Fireplace Logs Set, 1500W Fireplace Insert Log Heater, Overheat Protection, Remote... Rintuf Electric Fireplace Logs Set, 1500W Fireplace Insert Log Heater, Overheat Protection,... No ratings yet
15 35 Inch Electric Fireplace Inserts Recessed Electric Fireplace Heater with Log Designed for Stud,... 35 Inch Electric Fireplace Inserts Recessed Electric Fireplace Heater with Log Designed for Stud,... No ratings yet
16 LGHM 23' Electric Fireplace, 3DInfrared Black Fireplace Electric Insert Heater, with Wireless Remote... LGHM 23" Electric Fireplace, 3DInfrared Black Fireplace Electric Insert Heater, with Wireless... No ratings yet
17 R.W.FLAME Electric Fireplace Insert 37Inch with Adjuatble Flame Colors, Log Colors, Flame Speed and... R.W.FLAME Electric Fireplace Insert 37Inch with Adjuatble Flame Colors, Log Colors, Flame Speed...
18 Mxclimate 2pack Ember Retainer for Fireplace Grate, Keep Burning Embers from Falling, Fire Place... Mxclimate 2pack Ember Retainer for Fireplace Grate, Keep Burning Embers from Falling, Fire Place... No ratings yet
19 Tangkula 37 Inches Electric Fireplace Insert, Recessed and Freestanding Fireplace Heater with Touch... Tangkula 37 Inches Electric Fireplace Insert, Recessed and Freestanding Fireplace Heater with... No ratings yet
20 Tangkula 26 Inch 1400W Electric Fireplace Insert, 4777 BTU Recessed Freestanding Fireplace Heater... Tangkula 26 Inch 1400W Electric Fireplace Insert, 4777 BTU Recessed Freestanding Fireplace Heater... No ratings yet

SaleBestseller No. 1
Cheerway 18 Inches Electric Fireplace Insert for Mantel and Tv Stand, Realistic Flame Fireplace...
  • 【Size and Installation】:Overall Dimension: 18''W×17.5''H×5''D; This fireplace insert is designed only for recessed in fireplace mantel or TV...
  • 【Realistic Flame Effects】Realistic Flame effect fireplace heater, Life-like fire log set included, Ultra high intensity LED emulate realistic...
  • 【QIUET AND FLEXIBLE】Button control supported electric fireplace, heater no heat setting, very quiet air outlet, makes the fireplace a great...
  • 【Heater and Protection】The fireplace can be running with or WITHOUT HEAT; 1500W front heater, The supplemental zone heating is for up to 400...
  • 【Safety and guarantee】CSA certificated product. Free replacement or money back guarantee for any quality problem within 30 days, Free parts...
SaleBestseller No. 2
COSTWAY Electric Fireplace Inserts 23-inch Wide, 1500W Recessed Fireplace Insert with Remote...
  • 🔥 [Efficient Infrared Quartz Heating] The electric fireplace features infrared quartz tube & heating resistor wire for higher heating efficiency....
  • 🔥 [Impressive Flame Effect] This fireplace insert is designed with 6 flame colors and 5 brightness levels, delivering a perfect visual effect and...
  • 🔥 [Safe & Quiet Operation] The fireplace possesses CSA certification and overheating protection, thus to promise higher safety. Moreover, you can...
  • 🔥 [Easy to Control & Timer] All functions have individual button on remote control/control panel for easy operation, such as power(on/off), heater...
  • 🔥 [Practical & Attractive Heater] Our recessed electric fireplace with sleep mode(flame off + 1 level brightness + heater on) allows you to enjoy...
SaleBestseller No. 3
Joy Pebble Electric Fireplace Insert Log Heater 21",750W/1500W Adjustable 5 Flame Brightness&Speed,...
  • 【Realistic flames and flames speed】Electric Fireplace 3D Log Heater five flame brightness, that Projects infrared heat up to 10 feet and to...
  • 【2 heating modes, 30s fast heating】Our fireplace insert for Room heats up to 300 sq.ft, through electric heating wire, 750W (Warm) and 1500W...
  • 【Upgraded design & easy to use】Compared to other electric log, this fireplace Heater has Realistic Ember Bed with leaves decor and logs, electric...
  • 【Vent-free Heater】This is a cost-effective faux fireplace logs which means no need dealing with smoke and sweeping chimney,This Electric Fireplace...
  • 【Safe to Use&Satisfactory Service】This electric heater will shut off automatically when it gets too hot. Flame effect can be operated with or...
Bestseller No. 4
FLASLD Fireproof Fireplace Mat 24×42Inch Half Round Hearth Rug Protects Floors from Sparks Embers,...
  • 🔥【FLASLD Fireplace Mat Material】- Our fire resistent fireplace mat is made of double-sided silicone coated fiberglass fabric, allowing...
  • 🔥【Super Thin】- We developed this fireplace mat to protect the floor from charcoal splashing when the fireplace is burning. Its thickness is...
  • 🔥【Easy to Clean】- You can directly use a vacuum cleaner, a broom, or shaking to clean the fireplace protection mat. Besides, our fire resistent...
  • 🔥【Wide Application】- Our fiberglass fire resistent fireplace mat can protect floors, carpets, decks, garage floors, patios and other surfaces...
  • 🔥【Non-slip FLASLD Fireplace Mat】- The half round fire retardant hearth area mat is made of non-slip silicone cloth on front and back surfaces,...
Bestseller No. 5
PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound, Remote Control, 750/1500W,...
  • Overall dimensions: Width: 35 3/24" x Height: 22 7/16" x Depth: 8 25/32". For more dimension details, please refer to "User Manual" in "Technical...
  • 3 flame settings with variable intensity and brightness can be used with or without heat all year long; 100% energy saving LED technology. A sleek...
  • Life-like resin log which is 11 13/16" high sitting on the grate above ember bed, that's just what a wood burning fireplace looks like.
  • Adjustable thermostat; A supplemental heat for up to 400 sq. ft. CANNOT be used as a main heat source; Remote control provided for easy operation.
  • Easy to install and uninstall. With flat bottom, the insert can just sit on the floor directly; Plug in and use under a voltage of 120, CANNOT be hard...
Bestseller No. 6
LegendFlame 25" W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set (EF484), Fireplace Insert, Heater...
  • 25" W x 20" H x 10" D size suitable for free standing in small and large existing openings or cabinet. Very simple installation, just place it into...
  • Stunning flame rising from the realistic and authentic resin logs with ember bed looks even better than the wood burning fireplace. 100% energy saving...
  • Provides enough heat for a room of up to 400 square feet without any hassle of dust or smoke, or local wood burning regulations; However, this device...
  • Remote control is provided with 2 AAA batteries which is very convenient to use when you receive it.
  • One year limited warranty. Customer service is always ready for help whenever needed.
Bestseller No. 7
COSTWAY Electric Fireplace Insert 26-inch Wide, 5,000 BTU Recessed and Freestanding Fireplace Heater...
  • 🔥 [Multiple Flame Choices] The realistic dancing flame makes the fireplace a perfect decoration for your home. 3 flame colors (orange, blue and...
  • 🔥 [High-Performance Heating] The fireplace heater features 5,000 BTU heat output and can heat up to 430 Sq. ft, which will instantly drive away...
  • 🔥 [Panel & Remote Control] The functional control panel makes operation quite simple. And the convenient remote control with 20 ft effective...
  • 🔥 [High-Level Safety] This electric fireplace is both functional and safe, as it’s designed with overheat protection and certificated by ETL....
  • 🔥 [User-Friendly Fireplace] The 2 operating ways (flame only/flame and heat) make the fireplace suitable for all-season use. And it can be used in...
SaleBestseller No. 9
BWK1360 Fireplace Tray
  • Fast cleanup of fireplace ash
  • Expandable, to fit most standard fireplaces
  • No more ash buckets, brooms, or shovels!
  • The Fireplace Tray is crafted of 22-gauge, cold-rolled steel that's phosphate-treated to prevent rust.
  • The adjustable fireplace ash pan measures 2"-deep and 15"-front-to-back; the tray starts at 13" wide in back, 22" wide in front; expands up to 22-1/2"...
SaleBestseller No. 10
Ashley Hearth AW1820E 1,200 Sq. Ft. Wood Stove Insert , Black
  • 69,000 BTUs heats up to 1,200 Sq. Ft
  • Cast iron feed door with large 16.5" x 9" ceramic glass window and heavy gauge 3/16" reinforced plate steel with firebrick lining
  • Accepts logs up to 18 inches in length
  • Over 75% efficient heating
  • Replaces Vogelzang model TR004 and the US Stove Company 2200IE fireplace insert
Bestseller No. 11
PuraFlame Klaus Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound, Glass Door and Mesh Screen,...
  • Overall dimensions: Width: 31.89" x Height: 24.61" x Depth: 8.78". For more dimension details, please refer to "User Manual" in "Technical...
  • 3 flame settings with variable intensity and brightness can be used with or without heat all year long; 100% energy saving LED technology
  • Life-like resin log which is 11 13/16" high sitting on the grate above ember bed, that's just what a wood burning fireplace looks like. Traditional...
  • Adjustable thermostat; A supplemental heat for up to 400 sq. ft. CANNOT be used as a main heat source; Remote control provided for easy operation
  • Easy to install and uninstall. With flat bottom, the insert can just sit on the floor directly; Plug in and use under a voltage of 120, CANNOT be hard...
SaleBestseller No. 12
ORALNER Electric Fireplace Insert 23 Inch, 3-Sided Glass Fireplace Heater w/Remote Control & 8H...
  • 🔥【3-Sided Views & Realistic Flames】: The realistic flames dancing on the three sides of this electric fireplace's see-through glass add a touch...
  • 🔥【Easy Installation】: Save space in your home by recessing this fireplace heater in a cabinet (from back of mantel to insert). Use it in...
  • 🔥【Stylish & Modern Room Decor】: With its sleek and modern design, this electric fireplace heater will complement any decor style. The embedded...
  • 🔥【Great Heat Output & Ambience】: With a high-efficiency heating system that delivers 5,118 BTUs of heat output and heats up to 1,000 sq.ft.,...
  • 🔥【Remote Control with 8H Timer】: You can easily control the fireplace heater using the touch screen or adjust the settings from the comfort of...
SaleBestseller No. 13
Signature Design by Ashley 24" Electric Infrared Fireplace Insert with Remote Control, Black
  • TV STAND FIREPLACE INSERT: Enjoy the comforts of a crackling fireplace without the maintenance or cleanup. This fireplace insert unit is a cozy...
  • 7 PRE-SET TEMPERATURE SETTINGS: Flames operate with or without heat. Used as a heater, it warms up a mid-size room of 400 square feet. Built with a...
  • LED FIRE DISPLAY: LED display settings can be selected through a convenient remote control with 5 different brightness level options. Realistic wood...
  • CREATE A COZY FEEL: Simply plug in and easily set the mood with warm, flickering flames. Instructions included
  • DIRECT FROM THE MANUFACTURER: Ashley Furniture goes the extra mile to package, protect and deliver your purchase in a timely manner
Bestseller No. 14
Rintuf Electric Fireplace Logs Set, 1500W Fireplace Insert Log Heater, Overheat Protection, Remote...
  • [750/1500W Adjustable Heating] Rintuf electric fireplace logs has two heating options (Warm air: 750W, Hot air: 1500W), and temperature can be...
  • [Realistic & Adjustable Flames] The Rintuf electric log fireplace has 5 adjustable flame brightness/speed levels, and 4 adjustable flame sounds. This...
  • [Easy To Use & Operate] The size of fireplace heater insert is 9"Dx20"Wx19"H, suitable for installation in existing openings and cabinets. The...
  • [Low Noise & Safe Design] The Rintuf 20” electric logs has passed safety certification, featuring an overheat safety shutdown protection system and...
  • [Widely Used & Best Winter Items] Electric fireplace logs with heater with timer are suitable for various occasions, such as living room, bedroom,...
Bestseller No. 15
35 Inch Electric Fireplace Inserts Recessed Electric Fireplace Heater with Log Designed for Stud,...
  • 【FLEXIBLE CONTROL MODES】The remote control and touch screen make it easier to control every function of the electric fireplace, power switch,...
  • 【MULTIPLE FLAME MODES】7-level carbon bed flame effect;5-level carbon bed brightness adjustment;5-level carbon bed speed adjustment;5-level...
  • 【WARM & INVITING】The heat comes out the middle of the upper part of the front,which concentrate more heat and make it warmer;Temperature settings...
  • 【WELL MADE】Made with sturdy steel sturcture and flat tempered glass front panel,this electric fireplace adds pretty realistic flames and awesome...
  • 【SAFETY & COMFORTY】CSA Certificate Approved. It also has double overheat protection device to avoid the superheating. The heat is good for...
SaleBestseller No. 16
LGHM 23" Electric Fireplace, 3DInfrared Black Fireplace Electric Insert Heater, with Wireless Remote...
  • 【REALISTIC FLAME】 The 23" electric fireplace inserts have a beautiful and crisp LED display features a series animation consisting of glowing log...
  • 【300 SQUARE FEET OF HEATED SPACE 】The 4760 BTU heater provides effective heating up to 300 square feet, optimal for warming up the entire room....
  • 【FITS PERFECTLY】 Being the perfect measurement of 23 inches, this fireplace insert fits into almost every television stands, fireplace wall,...
  • 【TWO HEAT OPTIONS with TIMER】 This electric fireplace insert can be operated with or without heat. As a heater, you can adjust the heating level...
  • 【SAFETY & COMFORT】 ETL Certificate Approved. It also has auto-heat kill safety to avoid the superheating. The heat is good for maintaining the...
Bestseller No. 17
R.W.FLAME Electric Fireplace Insert 37Inch with Adjuatble Flame Colors, Log Colors, Flame Speed and...
  • Dimensions: 37" x 6.5" x 26.02". Freestanding & Recessed Fireplace Insert. Easy to be installed and ideal for all kinds of occasions such as home,...
  • MULTI OPERATING MODES: Touch Screen On Front Panel;4 flame & burning logs color modes;5 flame speed modes;5 flame brightness levels;Specially...
  • 2 HEAT SETTINGS & ENERGY SAVINGS: 750W & 1500W for different rooms and weathers which can be adjusted accordingly for both warm and energy saving...
  • FASHION DESIGN: Two-sided interior brick wall design.Constructed with 7mm thick tempering glass and the black finish, coordinated with gorgeous...
  • SAFETY:ETL Certificate Approved.170cm(about 70in) Power Cable. Wall mounted fireplace heater with LED fire & ice flame.The heat is good for...
Bestseller No. 18
Mxclimate 2pack Ember Retainer for Fireplace Grate, Keep Burning Embers from Falling, Fire Place...
  • Fireplace Ember Retainer: Our ember retainer is made of highest quality steel with black finish.high temperature and low temperature...
  • Efficient Fire:Wide ember retainer help hold wood and coals,keeps the wood embers in place longer for a hotter, more efficient fire.
  • Universal Size:16 L x 10 W inches designed to fit most fireplace grate,Which help holds embers stablely allowing only the ashes to fall below
  • Widely Used:Designed for wood burning fireplaces.ideal for indoor fireplace and outdoor fire pit
Bestseller No. 19
Tangkula 37 Inches Electric Fireplace Insert, Recessed and Freestanding Fireplace Heater with Touch...
  • Warm Your Room: Through the top air outlet ports, this 5100 BTU electric fireplace will deliver sufficient and stable warmth for you to heat a 400...
  • Enrich Your Space: The 4 flame color modes (red/yellow/orange/blue), 4 log color modes (red/yellow/red/orange), 5-level adjustable flame speed and...
  • 2 Types of Control: This recessed fireplace heater is available in 2 control methods that are touch panel and remote control. All the functions will...
  • Safe & Quiet to Use: This electric fireplace with ETL certification features overheat protection so that it will auto shut down once the temperature...
  • More Flexibility, More Possibilities: Whether you want it for freestanding on the cabinet or just recessed it in the cabinet, this functional electric...
SaleBestseller No. 20
Tangkula 26 Inch 1400W Electric Fireplace Insert, 4777 BTU Recessed Freestanding Fireplace Heater...
  • Perfect for Room Heating: Powered by 1400W, the electric fireplace produces a lot of heating quickly to warm your room up. Furthermore, it brings 400...
  • Vivid Ember Bed & Flame Effect: The vivid ember bed and flame create an authentic feel and add a warm atmosphere. What's more, the 3-level brightness...
  • Easy to Control: The digital control panel and remote control make it easy for you to adjust the power, flame, temperature and timer. The remote...
  • Safe & Efficient Operation: The fireplace insert heater comes with CSA certification and overheat protection for reliable use. Plus, the low noise...
  • Dual Using Methods: The freestanding fireplace heater can be placed on stand as mind, and can be recessed into the cabinet to save space. Please...
.