20 Best Consumer Reports Gas Fireplace Inserts in 2022 Reviews and Buying Guide

2,244 Reviews Scanned

# Preview Product Rating
1 Glass Fireplace Door Insert Fiberglass Insulation Sealing Kit Black 10 Feet Long Glass Fireplace Door Insert Fiberglass Insulation Sealing Kit Black 10 Feet Long No ratings yet
2 Kidde Carbon Monoxide Detector, AC Plug-In with Battery Backup, CO Alarm with Replacement Alert Kidde Carbon Monoxide Detector, AC Plug-In with Battery Backup, CO Alarm with Replacement Alert No ratings yet
3 Stanbroil Set of 4 Gas Logs Decorative Ceramic Pine Cones for Indoor or Outdoor Fireplaces and Fire... Stanbroil Set of 4 Gas Logs Decorative Ceramic Pine Cones for Indoor or Outdoor Fireplaces and... No ratings yet
4 AVAFORT 10 Piece Gas Fireplace Logs, Ceramic Wood Gas Fireplace Log Set for Propane, Gas, Gas... AVAFORT 10 Piece Gas Fireplace Logs, Ceramic Wood Gas Fireplace Log Set for Propane, Gas, Gas...
5 Skyflame Glowing Embers Rock Wool Mixed with Vermiculite for Vented Gas Fireplaces | Fake Coals for... Skyflame Glowing Embers Rock Wool Mixed with Vermiculite for Vented Gas Fireplaces | Fake Coals...
6 Oklahoma Joe's Longhorn Reverse Flow Smoker, Black Oklahoma Joe's Longhorn Reverse Flow Smoker, Black No ratings yet
7 Elgato Stream Deck - Live Content Creation Controller with 15 Customizable LCD Keys, Adjustable... Elgato Stream Deck - Live Content Creation Controller with 15 Customizable LCD Keys, Adjustable...
8 Real Fyre PT-1 Pilot Thermocouple for Natural Gas (NG) G45 and G46 Burner Applications Real Fyre PT-1 Pilot Thermocouple for Natural Gas (NG) G45 and G46 Burner Applications No ratings yet
9 Mr. Fireglass 10 Pounds Black Natural Lava Rock for Indoor Outdoor Gas Fire Pits Fireplaces |... Mr. Fireglass 10 Pounds Black Natural Lava Rock for Indoor Outdoor Gas Fire Pits Fireplaces |... No ratings yet
10 Barton 10-Piece Fireplace Logs Ceramic Logs Wood Fire Place Log Gas Heat Resistant Realistic Logs... Barton 10-Piece Fireplace Logs Ceramic Logs Wood Fire Place Log Gas Heat Resistant Realistic Logs...
11 Midwest Hearth Vermiculite Granules for Gas Logs - 12 oz Bag Midwest Hearth Vermiculite Granules for Gas Logs - 12 oz Bag No ratings yet
12 Durablow TR1001 Gas Fire Fireplace Remote Control Kit for Millivolt Valve, IPI Module, Replaces Wall... Durablow TR1001 Gas Fire Fireplace Remote Control Kit for Millivolt Valve, IPI Module, Replaces... No ratings yet
13 Midwest Hearth Platinum Embers for Gas Logs and Fireplaces (5 Grams) Midwest Hearth Platinum Embers for Gas Logs and Fireplaces (5 Grams) No ratings yet
14 Replacement Gasket Self-adhesive Wood Firebox Stove Window Tape Replacement Gasket Self-adhesive Wood Firebox Stove Window Tape No ratings yet
15 Pleasant Hearth 42 in. Radiant Zero Clearance Universal Vent Free firebox, Black - PHZC42F Pleasant Hearth 42 in. Radiant Zero Clearance Universal Vent Free firebox, Black - PHZC42F No ratings yet
16 Durablow TR1003 Gas Fire Fireplace On/Off Remote Control Kit + Thermostat + Timer for Millivolt... Durablow TR1003 Gas Fire Fireplace On/Off Remote Control Kit + Thermostat + Timer for Millivolt... No ratings yet
17 Stanbroil Vermiculite Granules for Gas Logs Vented or Unvented fireplaces - 12 oz Bag Stanbroil Vermiculite Granules for Gas Logs Vented or Unvented fireplaces - 12 oz Bag No ratings yet
18 Deluxe 36 inch Vent-Free Firebox - Flush Face Refractory Liner Deluxe 36 inch Vent-Free Firebox - Flush Face Refractory Liner
19 COSTWAY 28.5-Inch Electric Fireplace Inserts, 750W/1500W Wall Recessed and Freestanding Fireplace... COSTWAY 28.5-Inch Electric Fireplace Inserts, 750W/1500W Wall Recessed and Freestanding Fireplace... No ratings yet
20 Peterson Real Fyre 24' G45 Triple Burner System (NG) Natural Gas (Burner-System Only Logs Not... Peterson Real Fyre 24" G45 Triple Burner System (NG) Natural Gas (Burner-System Only Logs Not... No ratings yet

Bestseller No. 1
Glass Fireplace Door Insert Fiberglass Insulation Sealing Kit Black 10 Feet Long
  • Replacement Black Fireplace Door Insulation. This surrounds the fireplace behind the frame to block out air gaps. Better Seal to keep hot out from...
  • Size: 10' Long x 1.5" Deep Used to create a tight seal between fireplace inserts and existing masonry
  • Color: BLACK
  • Rated up to 225 F Replace insulation every time the fireplace insert is removed for cleaning
SaleBestseller No. 2
Kidde Carbon Monoxide Detector, AC Plug-In with Battery Backup, CO Alarm with Replacement Alert
  • CO detector alerts with a loud 85dB warning signal indicating dangerous levels of carbon monoxide in your home
  • Plug-in that still works during a power failure - 2-AA batteries (included) provide backup for your CO alarm in the event of a power outage
  • Easy & quick installation - plugs into any standard AC wall outlet
  • Purchase multiple alarms for whole-home detection - place 1 carbon monoxide detector on each level of your home & outside each sleeping area to help...
  • UL Certified, 10-year limited warranty
Bestseller No. 3
Stanbroil Set of 4 Gas Logs Decorative Ceramic Pine Cones for Indoor or Outdoor Fireplaces and Fire...
  • Four gas log set includes: 5.5" logs x1, 4.5" logs x1, 4" logs x1, 3.5" logs x1.
  • Made from high-quality ceramic fiber, these ceramic wood logs look just like real wood logs, you’ll even see some orange or red hot spots under the...
  • It's very safe, burn clean and do not release any ash or residue into the air. keep your family safe from any toxic fumes.
  • 4 piece set of ceramic logs decorate around the house or for fireplaces.
  • Great ambiance and durability, it's a great addition to gas logs, rock wood, glowing embers, fire glass, or lava rocks.
SaleBestseller No. 4
AVAFORT 10 Piece Gas Fireplace Logs, Ceramic Wood Gas Fireplace Log Set for Propane, Gas, Gas...
  • REALISTIC LOGS: Bring cozy and warmth feelings to your home. Our real-life look alike wood logs are made up of high quality safe ceramic fibre...
  • LARGE SIZE: The log set includes ten realistic wood like variation pieces. Four identical log pieces of 15”, two identical 14” logs, two identical...
  • CERAMIC MATERIAL: Made up of ceramic fiber that has a mimic glowing effect of red and orange glow like real burning wood . It is compatible to be used...
  • NON-TOXIC: - The logs burn clean and do not release ash or air particles like other competitor’s replica logs.
  • MULTIPLE USE: Can be used by itself or can be mixed with current gas logs, crackle flame firelogs, fire starters, glowing embers, fire starters, and...
Bestseller No. 5
Skyflame Glowing Embers Rock Wool Mixed with Vermiculite for Vented Gas Fireplaces | Fake Coals for...
  • Glowing embers compatible with NG and LP gas fireplace vented insert
  • Includes 6 ounces of rock wool with Vermiculite
  • For use as an indoor decorative gas fireplace accessories with sand lava rock and log set, long lasting, should never need replacing
  • Creates a realistic glowing fire coal bed for your gas fireplace, glows like real coals where the flame touches the embers
  • Proprietary blend of ember wool and mica flakes for a fantastic glow
Bestseller No. 6
Oklahoma Joe's Longhorn Reverse Flow Smoker, Black
  • The Longhorn Reverse Flow Offset Smoker provides the best for you outdoor cooking needs. With optional smokestack locations you choose between reverse...
  • Charcoal fuel allows you to grill with high heat or cook low and slow
  • 751-square-inches of primary cooking space; 309-square-inches of secondary cooking space
  • Heavy-gauge steel construction ensures durability you can trust
  • Professional temperature gauge for accurate monitoring
SaleBestseller No. 7
Elgato Stream Deck - Live Content Creation Controller with 15 Customizable LCD Keys, Adjustable...
  • Tactile Live Production: easily control your favorite tools and platforms.
  • 15 Customizable LCD Keys: instantly trigger unlimited actions with a tap.
  • Multi Actions: tap once to launch multiple actions simultaneously or sequentially with time intervals.
  • Smart Profiles: create unique key configurations for different apps, and switch between them on the fly.
  • Powerful Integrations: Elgato 4KCU, OBS, Twitch, YouTube, Twitter, Discord, Spotify, Philips Hue, vMix, VoiceMod, and more.
Bestseller No. 8
Real Fyre PT-1 Pilot Thermocouple for Natural Gas (NG) G45 and G46 Burner Applications
  • Genuine Real Fyre component by RH Peterson
  • Part number PT-1 NAT (Natural Gas)
  • For G45 and G46 burner applications
Bestseller No. 9
Mr. Fireglass 10 Pounds Black Natural Lava Rock for Indoor Outdoor Gas Fire Pits Fireplaces |...
  • Pure Natural Lava Rocks: Lava stone comes in a variety of sizes from 0.2" to 0.3". Volcanic rock is truly natural, available in black and red. No...
  • Eco-Friendly for Indoor and Outdoor Uses: Liquid propane or natural gas is compatible. These fire rocks are perfect to use with fire bowls, fire pits,...
  • Strong Heat Resistance: Black lava rock can resist extreme temperatures without damage and crumbling. By spreading the gas in all directions to...
  • Multifunctional for Decoration: As a base layer underneath fire glass and even mixing with the lava and glass together. Simply pour natural rocks into...
  • High Quality & Low Cost Fire Rocks: Easy to maintain, without discolor, fade or crumble. Porous surface without ash or smoke. Naturally occurring...
Bestseller No. 10
Barton 10-Piece Fireplace Logs Ceramic Logs Wood Fire Place Log Gas Heat Resistant Realistic Logs...
  • Great for All Type of Fireplace - Ceramic Wood Logs are perfect for all kind of fireplaces, like Vented gas fireplace, Outdoor gas fireplaces, indoor...
  • Perfect for Fireplace or Fire pit - Ten life sized ceramic gas logs that won't leave your fireplace looking bare
  • Creativity - Arrange your logs based on your needs. You receive (10) logs with different designs to allow you to use your creativity. Stack the logs...
  • Family Safe from Toxic Fumes - Natural Glow logs burn clean and do not release any ash or residue into the air like some lower quality fake fireplace...
  • Complement Piece - Can be used to complement current gas logs, crackle flame firelogs, fire starters, fire log, crackle flame fire logs, glowing...
Bestseller No. 11
Midwest Hearth Vermiculite Granules for Gas Logs - 12 oz Bag
  • HIGH QUALITY - Midwest Hearth vermiculite uses high-quality exfoliated vermiculite
  • INCREASED PERFORMANCE - Vermiculite helps in spreading gas throughout the entire burner pan of propane gas logs
  • ADDS REALISM - Adds realism to your gas fireplace | Sparkles and shines in the fire!
  • SAFE TO USE - 100% carbon monoxide and oxygen depletion safe and 100% asbestos free
  • LARGE 12oz BAG - Large 9" x 12" bag - 12 oz of vermiculite
Bestseller No. 12
Durablow TR1001 Gas Fire Fireplace Remote Control Kit for Millivolt Valve, IPI Module, Replaces Wall...
  • ★★ ATTENTION: This device is NOT a power supply unit. It is a switch designed for connecting to Millivolt valve, or to electric spark ignition...
  • ▼ All battery powered R.F. 2-button transmitter and receiver box kit gives wireless remote control to a gas heating appliance, such as gas...
  • ▼ Receiver with LEARN function, snap-on wall plate, and 18-inch wires with connectors to connect MILLIVOLT valve, or electric spark ignition module,...
  • ▼ Replaces Cross Reference Model #: SKY, 1001, 1001-A, 1001TH, 1001T, 1001D 1410, 1410T, 1410-A, 1410TH, RG04-1M, UN3. ▼ LEGAL DISCLAIMER: The...
  • ▼ Includes: Remote transmitter, receiver box, wall mount cover plate, screws, slide switch, wires with connectors, manuals / instructions. ▼ FCC...
Bestseller No. 13
Midwest Hearth Platinum Embers for Gas Logs and Fireplaces (5 Grams)
  • REAL PLATINUM CATALYST - Platinum Bright Embers are catalytic embers for your vented gas fireplace or log set
  • BRIGHTER - In addition to creating a bright flickering appearance like that of real wood ember beds, these embers radiate broadband infrared heat thus...
  • USE WITH ROCK WOOL - When placed on top of existing mineral wool ember beds, the catalytic embers combust unburned fuel from the burner to provide a...
  • 5 GRAM BAG - Contains one single bag of five (5) grams of Platinum Bright Embers. This is enough material to dress up log sets up to 42 inches when...
  • VENTED FIREPLACES ONLY - For compatibility with your unvented or vent-free gas fire, please consult with the OEM to ensure that your appliance has...
Bestseller No. 14
Replacement Gasket Self-adhesive Wood Firebox Stove Window Tape
  • Perfect high temp self stick tape.
  • 1000f fiberglass.
  • Also good for fireboxes.
  • 1/8" x 5/8" x 8'
Bestseller No. 15
Pleasant Hearth 42 in. Radiant Zero Clearance Universal Vent Free firebox, Black - PHZC42F
  • Available in sizes 32”, 36”, 42” Zero Clearance design for installation in tight spaces.
  • Can be paired with a mantel for a custom look.
  • Features a matte black interior for a clean finish.
  • Draw screen included.
  • Hood included.
Bestseller No. 16
Durablow TR1003 Gas Fire Fireplace On/Off Remote Control Kit + Thermostat + Timer for Millivolt...
  • ★★ ATTENTION: This device is NOT a power supply/Ignitor unit. (No voltage output itself, but passing voltage from your fireplace thermopile for...
  • ▼ Thermostat feature in transmitter turns ON/OFF when room temperature changes. It also operates the fireplace with the room temperature swings 1...
  • ▼ Receiver with LEARN function, snap-on wall plate, and 18-inch wires with connectors to gas MILLIVOLT valve or electric spark ignition module. ▼...
  • ▼ Replaces Cross Reference Model #: SKY, 9800322, 9800323, 9800324, 9800326, 9800328, 9800329, 9800550, 9800580, 1001-A, 1001, 1001TH, 1001T, 1410T,...
  • ▼ Includes: Remote transmitter, receiver box, wall mount cover plate, screws, slide switch, wires with connectors, manuals / instructions. ▼ FCC...
Bestseller No. 17
Stanbroil Vermiculite Granules for Gas Logs Vented or Unvented fireplaces - 12 oz Bag
  • Made of high quality exfoliated vermiculite.
  • Use in vented gas log set fireplaces utilizing propane gas.
  • Add sparkle and shine to the fireplace for additional effect.
  • 100% safe, carbon monoxide and oxygen depletion are safe and without asbestos.
  • Enhanced the real wood burning effect and evenly distribute the flame.
SaleBestseller No. 19
COSTWAY 28.5-Inch Electric Fireplace Inserts, 750W/1500W Wall Recessed and Freestanding Fireplace...
  • 🔥【Realistic & Vivid Flame Effect】Amaze your guests with the lifelike flames of this in-wall electric fireplace. The high-performance LED lights...
  • 🔥【Multiple Operation Modes】Equipped with wireless remote control and touch screen control panel for great convenience. The 0-8 hours timer, 2...
  • 🔥【Energy-saving Heater with Timer and Thermostat】Two heat settings (high 1500W and low 750W) can be adjusted accordingly to achieve energy...
  • 🔥【Reliable Safety & Superior Comfort】ETL certification recognizes it as a safe device to be used indoor. The overheat protection system will...
  • 🔥【Easy Installation & Modern Style】This electric fireplace heater is specially created for recessed mounting in walls. It perfectly fits into...
Bestseller No. 20
Peterson Real Fyre 24" G45 Triple Burner System (NG) Natural Gas (Burner-System Only Logs Not...
  • Vented gas fireplace burner system
  • Premium construction for long-lasting durability
  • Unique burner design creates a superior flame appearance
  • Fuel efficient design lowers the cost of operation
  • Size: 24 inches
.